Archive for the ‘Rational Reviews’ Category

Share

A Review of the debut novel by Aneesh Gokhale

Reviewers are not supposed to have emotions. They are supposed to be neutral in their evaluation of any book. Sometimes they are required to be brutal, to be unforgiving in their judgement of the book that they review.

I am generally neutral while reviewing any book. But it was difficult in this case!

The subject of the book was the rise of the Maratha power in the 18th Century and its reaching its peak – flying the Saffron high from the walls of the Attock fort! This was a subject very, very close to my heart and I would be very ruthless if someone messed up this book. Hardly any good English novel has been written about the Maratha history. This young author was doing something I had been longing to do, to write Maratha history in English and place it in front of the world!

And by God’s Grace, he succeeded in doing that!!

Sahyadris to Hindukush starts off fast like the Blitzkrieg Cavalry of the Marathas and takes you as the Saffron treads the barren lands of Central India, the fertile Gangetic plains, the lush fields of Punjab and finally the rocky terrain of the Indus Valley – the very cradle of the Hindu Civilization!

The author’s command over the English language used in the novel is what impressed (and inspired) me the most. The flow of the language is superb and the construction of the sentences to make them sound like they were spoken in the local dialects in the Medieval times. Attention to detail in various parts of the novel – including the Geographical accuracies – will surely take the reader on a roller coaster ride of the Indian sub-continent!

It is very clear that the author has toiled very hard and has studied and researched thoroughly before sitting down and penning the novel. Even the smallest habits and customs of the Marathas and also the Pashtun tribes seem to have been studied in great detail! I congratulate the author for completing this mammoth task!

However, in my personal opinion I would have been greatly pleased had the author increased the size of the novel. The novel is an odd 187 pages and I would have loved if the author had made it 500 pages!

Inspite of its small size, Sahyadris to Hindukush dazzles you! It makes you imagine each and every scene and battle depicted in its words. You wince at the dirty politics played in the Mughal court and also rejoice when the Maratha banner flutters on top of the Attock Fort walls!

A must read for any one who is interested in the happenings in India in the 18th Century. A sure fire engaging novel, I will surely recommend this one!

- Pranjal Wagh
30 Apr 2013

This work by Pranjal A. Wagh is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License

Share
Share

Review of the Novel by Ashwin Sanghi

This review is a part of the Book Reviews Program at BlogAdda.com. Participate now to get free books!

 

I am not going to write this book review in the normal manner. I will not make sections titled “Plot”, “Analysis” & “Verdict” as is the usual protocol world over. I want the readers to have a flow. Try to take them on a roller-coaster ride, thrill them because this is the same manner in which “The Krishna Key” is written! Though the book has some shortcomings, it definitely leaves the readers  wanting for more!

First and foremost, I am extremely grateful to Ashwin Sanghi for highlighting ancient Indian Culture and telling the Indian youth (And Old people) the extent of our prosperity and scientific advances when the rest of the world was still struggling with Stone Age.

For those who have come across Ashwin Sanghi for the first time, he is the author of the best-selling The Rozabal Line and award-winning Chanakya’s Chant. His third book – which by far seems the most deeply researched to me- is The Krishna Key.

Sanghi’s story starts with the introduction of the most interesting character of the book – Taarak Vakil, the poor little rich boy – who believes he is Kalki, Lord Vishnu’s 10th Avtar and is here on the planet to destroy all evil. I would have loved this character to be explored a little bit more but alas some sacrifices have to be made for the sake of the story.

Taarak’s first victim is Anil Varshney, a brilliant researcher who has stumbled upon something very mysterious, something which leads to the secret that Krishna – the Govardhan Giridhaari- had locked away somewhere to keep it safe from those seeking power. Anil Varshney’s death enters the protagonist – 45 years young Ravi Mohan Saini who teaches the history of mythology at St. Stephen’s College.Saini becomes an unlikely detective who uses his vast knowledge to track down his friend’s killer and solve this amazing riddle left by our beloved Blue God – Lord Krishna!

The book then takes you an amazing ride across the country and includes locations like Jaisalmer, Mt. Kailash, Somnath Temple and so on. The the trail is dotted by some more murders by none other than Taarak. Some more very interesting characters enter the fray – Inspector Radhika Singh, Mataji and Sir Khan being the prominent ones. I really wish, Sanghi had been able to color these characters more.

Although the story does get a bit complex due to the amount of information that this book contains it is definitely worth a read. There are some errors in the printed version which maybe due to careless proof-reading but I guess such errors will be rectified in the coming editions.

Sanghi follows the similar style of narrating the story as employed in Chanakya’s Chant – that of running two stories parallel to each other. One set 5000 years ago and the other as it happens in the 21st Century. However, this style seems unnecessary here as both the stories have hardly anything in common unlike Chanakya’s Chant. It does sometime seem that we are being re-told the story of Mahabharata in the parallel narrative.

However, according to me the real reason for reading this book is not the story and mystery that surrounds The Krishna Key, but the magnificent history of our country! The reason I say history and not mythology is because these incidences – Mahabharata, Ramayana have actually happened in this country, evidences of Pushpak Vimana and the possibility of Indians having the knowledge of Nuclear weapons have been found. Moreover, due to various external aggressions that took place over a period of time and the bad habit of not recording many historical events, the knowledge has been lost in the pages of time. But I am sure, on reading ‘The Krishna Key’ some proud Indians will definitely delve into the pages of history and strive to find out more about our civilization! And for that one should read ‘The Krishna Key’!

And for that, I thank you, Ashwin Sanghi!

- Pranjal Wagh

 

PS: A special mention has to be made for the man who drew all the wonderful illsutrations/maps in the book – Rupesh Talaskar! Great Work!!

Creative Commons License
This work by Pranjal A. Wagh is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License

Share
Share

An Indian Journey – Charles Foster

This review is a part of the Book Reviews Program at BlogAdda.com. Participate now to get free books!

Usually, I do not read travel books. Although I have read some across English and Marathi but those that I have read would be rated as one of the best in their category. I would definitely classify ‘In the Hot Unconscious’ in those ranks.

You feel this book. You feel you are in the same place where Charles Foster is. When you read it, Charles Foster ensures that he takes you with him on his travels to find something. He himself claims that sometimes he does not know what he was looking for. Foster is in India supposedly to collect and study leeches. But as he travels the nation, his experiences from the southern and northern extremities of India ensure that he finds something more as well.

Foster is initially in remote area of North India, stuck in a lodge due to the world famous red-tape of the Indian Babudom – The Bureaucracy of the Post-Raj India. Stuck inside the lodge he continues his work of collecting leeches and has a few encounters with the deadly diarrhea. Foster’s travels take him across North India as far as the Nepalese border. He meets various people on his travels, makes friends with few of them, despises some of them and goes on moving across the Indian lands.

Foster’s enchanting yet lucid narrative is laced with cynicism and followed by an honest opinion. The humor in his writings and also the lessons that we learn as a reader are based on the Zen philosophy. Foster does not view India like the rest of the West does. Foster dissects each situation and puts it and the people involved in it to the test of his sharp sarcasm and crisp cynicism. It is only after that he takes us to the opinion he forms about them.

As an Indian his cynical view of looking at things stings us at first. All of the West always raves about the mystical land that is India and never in any travels have I heard anyone take up this critical view – may it be related to religion, the people or the cultural aspects of life here. But as you proceed you indeed find out that what Foster observes is true!

Soon enough, the leeches disappear from his writings and the he takes us on a wild ride across India and allows us to discover it once again. He tells us true stories of Bob, the guru who detests Foster at first sight but who weeps because he can only assure his devotees and not actually rid them of this misery and then makes an attempt to like Foster later on. He tells us about his Sikh Friend of a Cheese farmer Jagjit, a true patriot who accompanies the author initially in the book but later gets bored of constant company of Foster. His writings also tell us horrifying stories of people losing their lives in search of Nirvana – the tale of an engineer who ties his hands and legs and drowns in a river is particularly chilling.

As T.S. Elliot has quoted –

The end of all our exploring

Will be to arrive where we started

And know the place for the first time

- Foster explores India and finds spiritual essence of the land and of himself. As the author himself says, sometimes he himself does not know what he was looking for.

In the hot unconscious An Indian Journey by Charles Foster
Published by Westland Tranquebar in India

- Pranjal Wagh

Creative Commons License
This work by Pranjal A. Wagh is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License

Share